Thursday, August 29, 2013

The Empty Child

Tomorrow I'm going to be asked to articulate to my advisor my current research interests so we can work on finalizing the list before the meeting in a couple of weeks. This is going to be a challenge, because my interests don't divide neatly into three lists; they divide into four. Theory, autobiography, childhood, and the long 19th Century.

I think my reading so far can be arranged along a scale of constructedness.

1) It begins most fundamentally with child subjectivity - does the child (within the text) have voice or agency?
     --The theory in play here is Said and subaltern theory,
     --and the texts that seem to fit are Maggie in Mill on the Floss and "Baa Baa Black Sheep": the more heavily autobiographical stories
2) Is the child's voice filtered through an adult recollection? Is it stylized or "finished"? In what ways?
     --The theories are of memory, and again autobiography.
     --The texts that come to mind are Joyce's Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man or any of the poetry which has been fitted to a prosody.
3) Does the child create, or Is the child re-interpreted through theories of education or psychoanalysis?
     -- Psychoanalytic theory would apply, as would historicism and new historicism.
     --Texts that fit might include anything by Henry James, who withhold's the child's subjectivity, or Anne Bronte, who writes as an educator.
4) Is the "child" a construct of the figurative space called "childhood" created by theory?
     --Rousseau's theories created the space, so he would be relevant as both text and theory.
     --Also, Hartley Coleridge fits here, in a blast of cruel irony.
5) Is the "child" a faceless inhabitant of an imaginative narrative structure?
     --Narrative theory and mythology cover this level of constructedness, or emptiness.
     --These children inhabit fairytales and fables, like Der Struwwelpeter, or George MacDonald, or The Water Babies.